What Is a Tax Preparer—and How Do You Choose the Right One?

Financial Horizons: Insights for Building Wealth and Securing Your Legacy

By Dr. Jose G. Cardenas, Chief Tax Strategist at The C & R Group, LLC

Let’s be honest—most people hear “tax preparer” and think, “That’s just the person who types my numbers into a computer.”

Wrong.

A true tax preparer is part translator, part bodyguard, and part financial coach. They take the chaos of your financial life—W-2s, 1099s, side hustles, business income, deductions, credits—and turn it into a clean, accurate tax return that keeps you compliant and helps you keep as much of your money as the law allows.

If you’re going to trust someone with your taxes, you should know exactly what a tax preparer is, what they do, and how to choose one who actually protects your wealth.

In this edition of Financial Horizons, we’re going to break it all down.

So… What Is a Tax Preparer?

A tax preparer is an individual who helps taxpayers complete and file their tax returns. That sounds simple, but here’s what’s hiding inside that definition:

• They gather your financial information
• They interpret tax laws and rules that apply to your situation
• They calculate your income, deductions, credits, and tax due
• They prepare and file your return with the IRS and state authorities

In short:

A tax preparer stands between your money and the government—and how good they are directly affects how much you keep.

But not all tax preparers are created equal.

The Core Job: Knowledge + Filing Requirements

The meme says it clearly:

“Tax preparers must be knowledgeable in tax laws and filing requirements to ensure that taxpayers receive the best possible return.”

That means your tax preparer should:

1. Stay Current on Tax Law

Tax rules change constantly—deduction limits, new credits, phase-out ranges, filing deadlines, reporting thresholds. A serious preparer:

• Studies annual tax law updates
• Understands how new rules hit real people and businesses
• Knows what changed from last year and what stayed the same

If your preparer hasn’t mentioned any tax law changes in the last couple of years, that’s a problem.

2. Know Which Forms You Actually Need

Different income = different forms. A knowledgeable tax preparer understands when to use:

• Form 1040 vs. business returns (1120, 1120-S, 1065, Schedule C, etc.)
• Schedules for itemized deductions, capital gains, rental income, etc.
• Additional forms for education credits, child and dependent care credits, foreign income, and more

You shouldn’t be the one guessing which form fits your situation—that’s their job.

3. Apply the Rules to Get You the Best Legal Result

“Best possible return” doesn’t just mean a big refund. Sometimes the best result is:

• Lower tax due and no surprise bill next year
• Proper handling of business or rental losses
• Planning moves that set you up for better results in the future (retirement contributions, entity choices, etc.)

A good preparer isn’t chasing a one-year refund high. They’re building a long-term tax strategy.

Tax Preparer vs. Software: Why a Human Still Matters

Can software file a tax return? Yes.
Can software sit across from you and ask, “What changed in your life this year?” No.

Here’s where a real tax preparer pulls ahead of plug-and-play software:

• Context: They see your entire financial picture, not just individual boxes on a screen.
• Questions: They know what to ask to uncover deductions and credits you might not realize you qualify for.
• ** judgment:** They help you choose between different filing options and elections, not just accept a default.
• Protection: They stand behind the return if questions or notices show up later.

Software files.
A tax preparer interprets, strategizes, and protects.

Types of Tax Preparers: Who Are You Dealing With?

When you say “tax preparer,” you might be talking about:

• Someone at a seasonal tax chain
• An independent professional with years of experience
• An Enrolled Agent (EA), CPA, or tax attorney
• A “friend of a friend” who “does taxes on the side”

You want to know who you’re letting into your financial life.

Look for:

• Credentials or experience: EA, CPA, or a proven track record working with situations similar to yours
• Specialization: Do they understand individuals only? Small businesses? Real estate investors? Self-employed professionals?
• Year-round availability: Are they there for you if a notice shows up in July, or do they vanish after April 15th?

The more complex your financial picture (business income, rentals, investments, multi-state issues), the more important it is to work with someone who does more than seasonal data entry.

What a Great Tax Preparer Does for You

Let’s take it from the top. A strong tax preparer should:

1. Gather and organize your information
   Ask for specific forms and documents
   Provide checklists or portals to keep things clean
2. Review your financial life—not just last year’s return
   Ask about job changes, business income, new investments, marriage, divorce, kids, moves, etc.
3. Build your tax return accurately
   Correctly report all income
   Apply deductions and credits you legally qualify for
   Choose filing status and elections with strategy, not laziness
4. Explain your results
   Why you owe or are getting a refund
   What changed from last year
   How to avoid surprises next year
5. Guide your next moves
   Whether to adjust withholding or estimated payments
   Whether entity changes or retirement contributions could help
   Which records to keep and for how long

This is where a tax preparer starts to look less like a data entry clerk and more like a financial ally.

What a Tax Preparer Is Not

To keep it real, your tax preparer is not:

• A magician who can make tax liability disappear without real strategies
• A license to cheat, “fudge” numbers, or hide income
• A substitute for personal responsibility—you still need to provide accurate information

If a preparer:

• Promises impossibly huge refunds
• Brags about “beating the IRS” with tricks
• Suggests you leave off income or make up deductions

…walk away. When things go wrong, your name is on that return, not theirs.

How to Choose the Right Tax Preparer

When you’re interviewing a tax preparer (and yes, you should be interviewing them), ask questions like:

• “What types of clients do you normally work with?”
• “How do you stay current on tax law changes?”
• “Can you help me with both tax preparation and proactive tax planning?”
• “What happens if the IRS has questions or sends a notice?”
• “How often do we review my situation—once a year or more often?”

You’re not just buying a service. You’re building a relationship with someone who touches the core of your financial life.

Tax Preparer vs. Tax Strategist: Why You Deserve Both

Here’s the upgrade most people never make:

• A tax preparer makes sure last year is reported correctly.
• A tax strategist helps design this year and next year so you legally pay less and build more.

At The C & R Group, LLC, we combine both:

• Clean, accurate tax preparation
• Ongoing guidance on entity structure, deductions, retirement planning, and cash flow
• A focus on turning your tax situation into a wealth-building strategy, not just a once-a-year chore

You don’t need to be wealthy to use that kind of service.
You become wealthier because you use it.

🔗 Read more at: https://thecrgroupllc.com/financial-horizons

📅 Ready to stop guessing and start working with a tax professional who actually understands strategy, not just software?
Book a consultation with Dr. Cardenas

About the Author

Dr. Jose G. Cardenas is a retired U.S. Army Finance Officer and the Chief Tax Strategist at The C & R Group, LLC. With a Doctorate in Business Administration and over 20 years of experience in tax planning and financial strategy, Dr. Cardenas helps individuals, families, and business owners legally reduce taxes, stay compliant, and build lasting wealth and legacy. Learn more at thecrgroupllc.com

📌 Disclosure

This article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended to serve as personalized legal, tax, or investment advice. Requirements for tax preparers and applicable tax laws vary by jurisdiction and can change over time. You should consult with a qualified tax professional regarding your specific circumstances. Dr. Jose G. Cardenas, DBA, provides tax advisory services through The C & R Group, LLC. Insurance and investment strategies may be offered through his role as a licensed financial professional affiliated with Experior Financial Group.

#FinancialHorizons #TaxPreparer #TaxPlanning #TaxStrategy #WealthBuilding #TheCRGroupLLC #VeteranAdvisor #FML100M